
Many parents assume that once their children have lived in Texas for six months, a Texas court must decide custody. A November 2026 decision from the Dallas Court of Appeals shows why that assumption can be costly.
Per the published opinion, in In re Marriage of H.B.B. and M.T., No. 05-25-01248-CV, 2026 WL 3382089 (Tex. App.—Dallas Nov. 6, 2026) (mem. op.), the Fifth District Court of Appeals affirmed a Collin County order dismissing a divorce and custody case so it could proceed in Ontario, Canada. Everyone agreed Texas was the children’s “home state.” The court held that a home-state court may still decline jurisdiction when another forum is more appropriate.
The ruling addresses three questions every family with ties outside Texas should understand:
- How “home state” jurisdiction works under the Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act (UCCJEA)
- When a Texas court may find itself an “inconvenient forum” under Texas Family Code § 152.207
- Why the forum non conveniens statute for injury cases does not protect a Texas-resident spouse in a divorce
The Fifth District hears appeals from both Dallas and Collin Counties, so this opinion matters for local families. As a Dallas divorce attorney team with more than 25 years in North Texas courtrooms, we see these cross-border questions more often every year.
Case Background: A Collin County Filing, a Family Rooted in Canada
The parties married in 2018 and registered their marriage in Canada. They lived and worked in Canada for most of the marriage, though their first child was born during a temporary stay in Massachusetts.
In August 2024, the family moved to Texas. About nine months later, on May 2, 2025, the father filed for divorce in the 417th District Court of Collin County. He asked that both parents be named joint managing conservators of their three young children, that he receive the exclusive right to designate the children’s primary residence, and that the court consider child-abduction prevention measures.
The mother, initially without a lawyer, responded within a week. She told the court she was a Canadian permanent resident in the U.S. on a visitor visa set to expire that summer. She alleged family violence during the marriage, including an incident that led Canadian child-protection authorities to remove the father from the home. She said she never agreed to a permanent move and could not legally work in Texas. She requested temporary child support and spousal support, among other relief.
After retaining counsel, the mother moved to dismiss or stay the case on forum non conveniens grounds and transfer it to the Superior Court of Justice in St. Catharines, Ontario. The trial court initially denied the motion. It named both parents temporary joint managing conservators, restricted the children’s residence to Collin County, entered a standard possession order, and ordered the father to pay child support.
The mother then sought reconsideration with more detailed evidence. She cited her expiring visa, her lack of income and housing after the lease ended, Canadian witnesses and records, and her ability to work legally in Canada. She had also filed for divorce in Ontario within weeks of the Texas filing.
After a hearing where both parents testified, the trial court reversed course. It dismissed the case and directed that any other relief be taken up by the Canadian court. The father appealed.
Legal Analysis: How the Dallas Court of Appeals Decided the Case
The father raised two issues. First, Texas was the children’s home state, so the trial court could not send custody elsewhere. Second, Texas law barred dismissal because he is a Texas resident.
The court reviewed both rulings for abuse of discretion, a deferential standard. M. v. J., No. 05-21-00125-CV, 2023 WL 3914554, at *4 (Tex. App.—Dallas June 9, 2023, no pet.) (mem. op.).
Must Texas Hear a Custody Case If It Is the Child’s Home State?
No. A child’s “home state” is where the child lived with a parent for at least six consecutive months immediately before the case was filed. Tex. Fam. Code § 152.102(7). Texas generally has jurisdiction to make an initial custody determination when it is the home state. Id. § 152.201(a)(1).
The court agreed Texas was the home state here, so the trial court had jurisdiction. But having jurisdiction is not the same as being required to exercise it.
The father relied on P. v. S., 165 S.W.3d 322 (Tex. 2005), where the Texas Supreme Court held that home-state status turns on a child’s physical presence rather than a “totality of the circumstances” test. The Dallas court noted that P. also recognized a home-state court may defer to a more appropriate forum under § 152.207. The home-state court makes that call, and here a Texas court did exactly that.
What Are the UCCJEA Inconvenient-Forum Factors?
Section 152.207(b) requires a Texas court to consider all relevant factors, including:
- Whether domestic violence has occurred and is likely to continue, and which state can best protect the parties and child
- How long the child has lived outside Texas
- The distance between the courts
- The parties’ relative financial circumstances
- Any agreement about which state should hear the case
- The nature and location of the evidence
- Each court’s ability to decide quickly
- Each court’s familiarity with the facts
Section 152.105 directs Texas courts to treat a foreign country as if it were a U.S. state for this analysis.
The mother presented evidence on every factor. She testified about family violence and said her witnesses and hospital records were in Canada. The family had lived in Texas only about nine months, and the father’s counsel acknowledged they had lived in Canada for most of the marriage.
The courts sit more than 1,000 miles apart. The father was employed in Texas, while the mother could not work here and was relying on community organizations. Canadian witnesses were beyond the 150-mile subpoena reach of Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 176.3, and the marital property was in Canada.
The mother’s visa would prevent her from appearing in Texas, while the father, a dual citizen, could appear in either country. On that record, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in finding Canada the more appropriate forum for custody.
Can a Texas Divorce Be Dismissed If One Spouse Lives in Texas?
Yes, in the right circumstances. The father argued that Civil Practice and Remedies Code § 71.051(e) bars forum non conveniens dismissal when the plaintiff is a Texas resident. The court explained that § 71.051 applies only to personal injury and wrongful death actions. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 71.051(i).
Divorce cases fall under the common-law doctrine instead. Under Lee v. Na, 198 S.W.3d 492, 495 (Tex. App.—Dallas 2006, no pet.), and Sarieddine v. Moussa, 820 S.W.2d 837, 839 (Tex. App.—Dallas 1991, writ denied), a court may decline a divorce case when another forum better serves the parties, the witnesses, and the interest of justice. The movant carries the burden.
Here, Canada had substantial connections to the marriage, finances, property, and witnesses. Deciding everything in one forum also avoided duplicative litigation and inconsistent rulings.
In a footnote, the court found the Hague Convention inapplicable. It addresses the return of wrongfully removed children, not underlying custody disputes, and neither party relied on it at trial. In re A.S.C.H., 380 S.W.3d 346, 351 (Tex. App.—Dallas 2012, no pet.).
Practical Implications for North Texas Families
Section 152.207 is discretionary, and appellate courts give trial judges wide latitude. The case also shows that a trial court can revisit an earlier denial once the evidence is fully developed.
Families who recently moved to Dallas, Collin County, or cities like Richardson that straddle both counties should know that time in Texas, the location of witnesses, and where property sits can matter as much as the six-month clock. An experienced Dallas child custody lawyer can evaluate those facts before anyone files.
Financial relief is affected too. The trial court’s dismissal order sent all remaining requests for relief to the Canadian court, which means questions of support would be decided under another system. A Dallas child support lawyer can help you understand what is at stake if a forum challenge succeeds.
The opposing spouse may also be preparing a forum argument of their own. A Dallas divorce attorney who anticipates that motion early can gather school records, medical providers, and local witnesses to show the court why Texas remains the right place for the case.
Key Takeaways for Dallas Divorcing Couples
- Home-state status gives Texas jurisdiction but does not guarantee Texas will keep the case.
- Courts weigh family violence, finances, evidence location, and how long the family has lived here.
- Section 71.051’s resident protection does not apply to divorce.
- A Texas court can decline custody and, in the right case, dismiss the divorce as well.
- If your family recently relocated, talk with a Dallas divorce attorney before filing.
For more analysis of recent appellate decisions, visit our family law blog.






